When Is It Acceptable to Say "I Love You"?
If you're reading this, be bold!
Daniela Zoé A., thank you for your request.
We've all heard the theories. Some say two months in is way too soon, while others have been in relationships for two years and can count on one hand how many times they’ve said it—if ever. For some, those three words hold so much weight that they might as well be engraved in stone, too precious to be uttered lightly. For others, it’s not about the words themselves but about expressing love in any form—whether that’s through grand gestures, morning texts, or simply showing up.
But if there's one thing everyone agrees on, it's that saying I love you for the first time is a high-stakes moment. It can define a relationship. It can shift its course. And most terrifying of all—it can change how we see ourselves.
Before we even get into when to say it, maybe we should talk about what we're actually saying. Does I love you mean I am in love with you, or does it mean I care about you deeply? Because if it’s the former, then I’ve probably said it prematurely before. But if love exists on a spectrum—if we can love without being in love—then maybe I get a free pass.
We throw the word love around so easily in non-romantic contexts. We love our friends, our family, our pets, our favorite TV shows, the smell of fresh bread, the feeling of sun on our skin. But when it comes to romantic love, those three words suddenly carry an unbearable weight. Maybe because romantic love has expectations.
If I tell my best friend I love her, she doesn’t immediately wonder if we should move in together. If I say it to my dog, he wags his tail and goes about his day. But say it to someone you’re dating, and suddenly the stakes feel impossibly high. Are we ready for the level of commitment those words imply? And what if we say it and don’t hear it back?
If you’re playing it safe, you might wait for that perfect moment—when the stars align, your heart is certain, and there’s zero chance of emotional disaster. But let’s be real: love, much like life, is never risk-free. Saying I love you is a leap of faith, a confession wrapped in vulnerability and sealed with a silent hope: Please, let them feel the same way. Some people are firm believers in waiting.
They need time to be sure, to confirm that what they’re feeling isn’t just infatuation, passion, or an addiction to the honeymoon phase. For them, saying I love you too soon is like placing a bet before you’ve seen all the cards. Others believe in saying it as soon as they feel it. Why hold back on something beautiful? Why wait when you know? Love, to them, is meant to be spoken and lived fully, without hesitation.
And then there are those who wait because they fear rejection. They feel the words bubbling up, but they choke them down, terrified of what happens next. What if their partner doesn’t say it back? What if saying it too soon makes them seem needy or desperate? But here’s the thing: waiting too long can be just as damaging as saying it too soon. If one person in a relationship is craving those words and the other holds back, doubt starts to creep in. Do they feel the same? Are we on the same page? Love, after all, is not just about what we feel—it’s about what we express.
And yet, some people don’t need to hear it. Some believe actions speak louder than words. After all, someone can say I love you a thousand times and never truly show it. And someone else can love you fiercely without ever needing to verbalize it. But here’s the catch: we are verbal creatures. We long for words, for the reassurance that love isn’t just something we assume, but something we know. So even if love can exist unspoken, there’s something undeniably powerful about hearing it said out loud.
If we boil it down, the hesitation to say I love you is rooted in one thing: fear. Fear of rejection, fear of commitment, fear of being the one who feels more. But isn’t that what love is? A risk? The most terrifying and exhilarating part of love is that it requires vulnerability. Saying I love you is like stepping out onto a ledge without knowing if there’s solid ground beneath you. Maybe the other person catches you. Maybe they don’t. But isn’t it still worth it to say it anyway? Because if you love someone—truly love them—isn’t it worse to hold it in?
And then, of course, there’s the Ted Mosby of it all. In How I Met Your Mother, Ted tells a woman he loves her on the first date. Ballsy, right? Most of us would never dream of dropping the L-word that early. But the truth is, Ted Mosby is kind of the hero we all need. He loves fearlessly. He believes in grand gestures. He doesn’t wait for the perfect moment—he creates it. And honestly? If more people had a little Ted Mosby energy, maybe love wouldn’t feel so terrifying.
At the end of the day, there is no universal timeline. There’s no magic number of weeks, no set rulebook. Love doesn’t follow a script. So maybe the real question isn’t when to say I love you, but why we’re waiting. Maybe the right time is simply when you mean it. And if that means saying it too soon, so be it. If it means waiting, that’s okay too. But don’t let fear be the thing that holds you back. Because love—real love—is never about perfect timing. It’s about feeling something so deeply that you can’t help but say it out loud.
So if you love someone, tell them. If you’re not sure, take your time. But if you’re terrified? Well, congratulations. That means it matters.
With love,
Victoria (your fake Carrie Bradshaw)
Follow me on Instagram for daily updates on my latest articles! @viccolonne
Five articles I think you might like !
With You, or Not at All? The Ego’s Toughest Lesson in Love
Are Second Chances an Endangered Species?
Forgive and Forget? Navigating the Limits of Forgiveness in Relationships